Many are still left with the misperception that the Pope condemned the war in Iraq. I hope this post from the Corner’s Peter Robinson will help you all.
THE PONTIFF AND THE EUROBABBLERS [Peter Robinson]
Impossible though it may be to quote a papal condemnation of the war
in Iraq, lots of emails quoted statements against the war by Vatican
officials other than the Pontiff, notably by Cardinal Soldano, the
secretary of state, Cardinal Martino, the Vatican’s permanent observer
at the United Nations, and the former nuncio to the United States,
Cardinal Laghi. “What does it matter,” one correspondent asked, “that
the Pope himself didn’t condemn the war if his agents did?”
It matters a lot.
No one in the Church has any standing or authority that even
approaches that of the Pope, as Soldano, Martino, and Laghi themselves
understand. Read their anti-war statements carefully and you’ll find
them making it clear that they’re speaking for themselves or for “the
Vatican,” by which they mean the secretariat of state—that is, the
Vatican diplomatic corps—but never directly on behalf of John Paul II.
When Church officials speak as diplomats, moreover, the faithful owe
them no more allegiance than they would to any other diplomats. In
perfectly good conscience, in other words, a Catholic may conclude
just what I have concluded, namely that Soldano, Martino, and Laghi
have spent the last couple of years talking nonsense, all three
suggesting that a war can prove just only if condoned by the United
Nations, without, however, helping the faithful to grasp, a) how the
question of justice is affected by having an action ratified by a
body, two-thirds of whose membership is made up of dictators,
oligarchs, and nickel-and-dime tyrants, or, b) why the same Vatican
diplomats opposed the first Gulf War, even though that action was
indeed condoned by the United Nations.
With a clear conscience and in perfect justice, it is possible to say
of Soldano, Martino, and Laghi what would be quite wrong to say of the
Pope: That they deserve no more respect or consideration than
Dominique de Villepain or any other practitioner of mere Eurobabble.
Click to continue »