This is a tremendous article from Human Events that dispels the conventional myths surrounding Jerry Kilgore’s recent loss to governor-elect Tim Kaine. The media, the Democrats and moderate Republicans are touting Kilgore’s defeat as a political failure for conservatism and the Bush agenda. On the contrary: Far from running as an avowed conservative, Kilgore consistently shunned conservative principles throughout his campaign. The other two state candidates in VA, Bill Bolling and Bob McDonnell, won large victories on traditional conservative platforms. Kilgore, however, took unbelievably weak and ambiguous stances on abortion, guns and taxes (You can see this on full display in the first debate with Tim Kaine and moderator Tim Russert). The Kilgore campaign should be a harsh reminder that the Republican Party must embrace, not scorn, its conservativve ideals. Conservative leaders, like McDonnell and Bolling, will always be more successful than spineless, visionless politicians like Jerry Kilgore.
These parts of the article were particularly insightful:
“In striking contrast to his two Republican running mates—and to Bush himself in his winning campaign against John Kerry last year—Kilgore not only failed to deploy the tested conservative issues of taxes, abortion, and guns but actually seemed to run away from them. As one Republican Party leader from the nominee’s own Southwest Virginia home area told me: “Jerry attacked Kaine, all right, but never spelled out what he was in favor of. This was the worst campaign [for governor] that was ever run!”
While Kilgore repeatedly said he opposed any new taxes, he refused to sign the pledge of Grover Norquist’s Americans for Tax Reform that puts in writing a vow never to raise present taxes or support new ones. According to ATR spokesman Chris Butler, “Grover and the rest of us repeatedly urged Mr. Kilgore to sign the pledge, but he wouldn’t do it. The conservative Bolling, by contrast, proudly signed the ATR pledge. Noting that Bolling won 40,000 more votes than Kilgore, Butler said: ‘Had Mr. Kilgore signed the pledge, he would have won.’”
Alas. Conservatives should adopt the following rallying cry for the 2006 elections: “No More Jerry Kilgore’s!”