Sen. Kyl – this year’s Secrecy Champion – has several as-yet-unstated objections to the Freedom of Information Reform Act, a truly wonderful bill that would significantly improve one of the strongest tools Americans have to supervise the inner workings of government and to hold elected officials accountable.
The bill has plenty of bipartisan support. It is the product of tireless work and advocacy by many open government and press freedom groups and fine legislative craftsmanship by Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman John Cornyn (R-Texas) and Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.). The U.S. House of Representatives in March approved a version of the bill with 80 Republicans joining 228 Democrats for a 308-117 vote.
The Senate Judiciary Committee then unanimously sent the measure forward to the full Senate for a vote.
In your civics book, this would be the moment where our senators hold a public debate on the merits and demerits of the legislation at hand, then vote. The votes are then counted, and if the senators who support the bill outnumber those who oppose it, well, you get the idea.
But no, not when senators, using an archaic parliamentarian parlor trick, can stop a bill dead in its tracks merely by telling their party’s Senate leader or secretary that they wish to place a hold on the bill. That’s when Sen. Kyl – who routinely charts a brave course on the immigration debate and can often be counted on to reason rather than bloviate – slipped in the hold.
The Politico
Why would Jon Kyl, a “conservative” who wants to give amnesty to 12 million illegal immigrants, be opposed to having a vote on a bill that would open up the doings of our government to the public? This is a bill that has overwhelming support in both Houses of Congress. Wouldn’t a conservative push for transparency in government rather than secrecy? I also don’t like this idea that members of the Senate even have this option, that just one Senator from one state can make a decision for all 300 million people in this country. They need to do away with this rule.
Perhaps it’s time for Senator Kyl to retire to a bungalow in Boca and take up golf. Senator Flake would have a much better ring to it anyhow.